One of the things you learn very early in politics is the lesson that the political pendulum always swings.
In 2010, Barack Obama lost 63 seats in the U.S. House and 6 U.S. Senate seats. Did they seem particularly bothered back then?
During the Gingrich Revolution of 1994, Bill Clinton lost 54 seats in the U.S. House and 8 U.S. Senate seats. How did Clinton do in 1996?
During the 1982 midterms, the Democrats picked up 26 seats in the U.S. House in a national rebuke against a president who inherited double-digit inflation and a spiraling economy. Two years later, President Ronald Reagan led the nation in a 1984 LANDSLIDE VICTORY against Walter Mondale.
Anyone remember 2009? Barack Obama carried Virginia by 6 points in 2008. Governor Bob McDonnell came back just one year later and smashed his opposition with a whopping 58.6% of the vote.
Meanwhile, even in states where Democrats did well, conservative ballot initiatives passed in places conservatives never expected to win:
- In North Carolina, voters approved measures to cap the income tax at 3.5%, limit property tax increases, and require photo ID for mail-in ballots.
- Wisconsin voters passed a measure to ban affirmative action in state institutions.
- Indiana is on track to approve a constitutional amendment requiring a two-thirds majority of the legislature to raise income tax rates.
- Ohio passed a measure to require voter ID in the state constitution.
The American people are not rejecting conservative values; they are rejecting politicians who stray from those values. A small dose of humility and a heavy dose of Milton Friedman can go a long way.
Yet before I go into where I see things for us in Virginia, let me re-iterate our role here at Jefferson Forum as a non-profit, non-partisan, free market organization committed to the principle of freedom. I am not here to adjudicate winners and losers in elections.
I am here to say that good policy gives good leadership the right tools to move mountains. Virginia hasn’t run out of heroes yet, and in the best of Virginia traditions, if there are enough conservatives still willing to fight for what we believe in, then a return to victory isn’t a matter of if — just when.
Moving forward, I see the battlespace in clear terms:
1. We Need to Win Policy Fights in Richmond
The second year of any gubernatorial term in Richmond is always the one where we see the most activity. Jefferson Forum is well placed to put a blazing spotlight on each and every bad piece of legislation that comes through the General Assembly and then put scrutiny on the ones that need to fail.
Remember that just because there are legislative majorities does not guarantee policy victories. With a 21-19 Senate, recent scandals and indictments, and the entire nation watching? Virginia conservatives have turned back bad bills before.
2. We Need Something to Fight FOR
Don’t be confused about the message that was sent last night. When Anne Holton — yes, that Anne Holton — gets defeated by a socialist for Richmond school board, that tells you the Democratic Party isn’t hiding the football anymore and are making the choice for socialism.
Of course, any student of history knows socialism isn’t going to solve a single one of these problems for Virginia families. In fact, they will make these problems worse.
Most of all, conservatives need something to fight for.
It is time to recapture the public imagination and build on the opportunity society that made America great in the first place.
So how can conservative values restore faith in American freedom?
We made a promise to end the car tax and we should keep that promise. If Tennessee can abolish the income tax and unleash economic freedom, so can Virginia. If other states can reduce the cost and complexity of health care, increase access to workforce empowerment, and reduce the size, burden, and scope of government? So can we.
Jack Kemp was quick to remind his friends in heavily liberal districts: If what’s working for you isn’t working for you, give conservatives a chance. If we don’t do what we say we are going to do? Throw us out.
I can promise you this.
Jefferson Forum will continue to advocate for bold conservative solutions that give people a choice between the failures of the past and the promise of a better future.
It’s time to lead again.
3. Above All Else, We Need to Stay Engaged in the Fight
In December 1776, the Continental Army was on the verge of collapse. Thomas Paine wrote back then about “fair weather patriots” in his letter The American Crisisand the times that try mens souls.
General George Washington knew that the Continentals needed a win. Trenton was that win, and it kept a fledgling army going. Valley Forge was still in front of them, but what came out of Valley Forge was the core of true believers who carried the patriot cause through the War for Independence and ultimately to victory at Yorktown in 1781.
History is made by those who show up.
Yet as Margaret Thatcher reminds us, first we win the argument, then we win the vote. If we don’t win on ideas, then we can’t win on anything.
It’s time for the conservative movement to become a movement of big ideas again. As Virginians, we come from a history of heroes who understood the promise of self-government and the rewards of free markets, free ideas, and a free society.
Just remember that in 1982, the political left told us to give up back then, too.
But without 1982’s midterms, we would have never gotten to 1984’s landslide.
If we had listened to the doomsayers, Reagan would never have defeated the Soviet Empire, the Berlin Wall would have never come down, the economy that powered the Peace Dividend would never have lifted billions out of poverty and put millions of Americans into the middle and upper class.
I still believe in that kind of America. I still believe in that kind of Virginia as well. More than this, I know in my bones that Virginia hasn’t run out of heroes.
So stay positive!
Keep in mind that political pendulums always swing. It’s just a question of what kind of victory we want and what sort of future you and I are willing to work for.
Yours in Conservative Victory,

Shaun Kenney
President and CEO
Jefferson Forum
PS: Typically this is where I ask you for a contribution of some sort.
Instead, I want your ideas. Just respond to this e-mail and share with me your thoughts, observations, ideas, and solutions moving forward. Be confident about two solid and known truths: (1) socialism fails every time, and (2) human freedom is an absolutely unstoppable force once unleashed.
And if it is a very good idea, we can talk about making it happen.
More on that front and soon. . .

