Taxing Talent and Farmland is Bad Policy for Virginia

Commentary By

Michael Torres

Michael Torres serves as a fellow for the Jefferson Forum, where he primarily focuses on education policy. He is also the director of legislative strategy for Classic Learning Initiatives, where he manages multi-state government affairs initiatives concerning school accountability, college admissions, and school choice policies.

Shaun Kenney

SHAUN KENNEY is the President & CEO of Jefferson Forum.  

Shaun Kenney

SHAUN KENNEY is the President & CEO of Jefferson Forum.  

Commentary By

Shaun Kenney

SHAUN KENNEY is the President & CEO of Jefferson Forum.  

I’m always curious about the whole idea of budget shortfalls. For instance, if I have a budget shortfall in my family budget, typically this means I have to cut from some other portion of my budget.

Not so with state government.

Last year, Virginia saw a bill that would hit anyone making over $1 million a year with a 10% tax bracket. The attraction for Richmond is the potential to raise $1.5 billion, with 50% going to public schools, 30% to the Child Care Subsidy Program, and 20% to the Virginia Housing Trust Fund. Sounds great, right? Who doesn’t support education, child care, or housing? Only a cold hearted reptillian, I suppose.

Of course, in Washington State where lawmakers toyed with the idea of a millionaire tax, the New York Times recently reported that the experiment on soaking the rich has been tried and spectacularly failed:

The millionaires tax, along with the election of progressive and socialist candidates, including Mayor Katie Wilson of Seattle, sends a signal to businesses that they are no longer valued, they say.

“This has gone from one of the most attractive places to start a business to the least attractive,” said Brian Heywood, a hedge fund millionaire whose political action committee collected more than 500,000 signatures to place the tax repeal on the ballot.

Not just did the so-called millionaire tax drive out talent from Seattle, but the slope is a slippery one indeed. Proponents will argue that the tax will only touch the top 19,000 Virginians — but brackets can always be expanded and contracted each year as the income tax becomes more progressive over time.

Unfortunately, the effort to repeal the tax-on-talent in Washington failed this November. Yet the problem of sending a message to business owners large and small remains.

One can imagine the family farm in Virginia whose income is over the threshold and finds themselves in a more expensive tax bracket. Or the small business that finally finds success only to be punished by Richmond for being successful, opening new locations, and employing more people at the unaffordable and poorly-decided $15 minimum wage.

Be Honest: It’s a Tax-On-Talent

This year, Senator Mamie Locke (D-Hampton) is proposing a similar bill, with slightly altered beneficiaries and a few technical amendments:

  • 40% to additional basic aid funding for public schools
  • 35% to the Child Care Subsidy Program
  • 25% to the Virginia Housing Trust Fund

The argument in support of a tax-on-talent is simple enough. Few people will be targeted, they’re all millionaires who can afford it anyway, and it is for the children.

The counterpunch to this is that if you are the sort of talent with those kinds of resources, you will move to a state that doesn’t punish you for success. Or in a more deconstructive sense, you simply won’t gamble on growing your business large enough to put oneself in a higher tax bracket only to have the hard work siphoned off by big government, per the Tax Foundation:

International precedents have shown high administrative costs, capital flight, and disappointing net revenue when wealth taxes are imposed. Such taxes penalize saving and investment, the foundations of capital formation, innovation, and wage growth—ultimately slowing economic expansion that benefits all residents. In a federal system with free movement, they accelerate the exodus of both people and productive capital to more tax competitive states, such as Florida and North Carolina.

These worrying trends of unsound tax policies risk a self-reinforcing cycle. By further narrowing the tax base to a small, highly mobile segment, states increase revenue volatility. On top of such measures, high income property-focused surcharges, like New York’s pied-à-terre tax, add complexity and valuation challenges while signaling an unwelcoming environment for wealth.

This is hardly the stuff of fairness. Fairness in a basic sense means that you are not entitled to the hard work of others. If socialism is the bedtime story told by envy and taxes are the so-called price we pay for civilization, then sound economic policies that foundationally support free enterprise are the price we pay for the taxation to support government.

Good Intentions are Rarely Sound Policy

Of course, taxing the elites as a sort of avant garde flair to it. The problem is that those with the means simply move to places that support free enterprise, leaving the higher taxes and barriers to entry behind to those who cannot afford to escape socialist policies.

I have no doubt that Senator Locke’s intentions are sound. In fact, they are laudable in the extreme. We all want people to pay their fair share for a stronger education system, better public services, and increased access to the American Dream. After all, this is what a good politics entails.

Yet we should not solely judge legislation by its good intentions, but rather by their results. Across the nation, this tax-on-talent only pushes those with the means to do business elsewhere to do precisely that, leaving those who remain behind with the additional hoops and regulations and artifices which push their chance at that same dream a bit farther away.

One solution? Try eliminating the income tax altogether. Tennessee has successfully done so and businesses in Virginia are taking advantage by relocating to sunnier climates for free enterprise. Creating more opportunities for individuals to start their own businesses without worrying how Richmond is going to punish them for trying would be sound.

Working class families are already feeling the bite of the affordability crisis. It is unfortunately a death of a thousand cuts — a tax here, a regulation there, a good idea cloaked as a “millionaire tax” when really it is talent being taxed.

We can solve a lot of problems with economic growth. Virginia has opportunities of location few other states in the nation enjoy. Let’s not squander that environment by plowing salt into the fields of economic empowerment. Unleash that potential and there will be plenty to fix the problems of the world.

Share This Commentary

More on the Same Issue